FCA proposes greater pension investment flexibility to support long-term value for savers
AI Analysis
The FCA is consulting in CP26/40 on excluding qualifying performance-linked fees from the 0.75% annual charge cap for default funds in FCA-regulated contract-based workplace pension schemes. The permissive exemption is intended to facilitate greater investment in private equity, venture capital and private credit, aligning contract-based schemes more closely with trust-based schemes while adding safeguards on value for money, fee transparency, fair allocation and private-asset valuation.
Key dates
- 2026-11-12
- FCA CP26/40 consultation opens.
- 2027-01-14 Deadline
- Deadline for responses to FCA CP26/40.
- 2027-06-30
- FCA currently expects to make final rules in summer 2027; the precise publication and commencement date has not been specified.
Suggested considerations
- Compliance teams may wish to assess whether existing or planned private-market investments in default funds generate performance-linked fees that are currently included in the 0.75% cap calculation.
- Providers should consider preparing a consultation response by 2027-01-14, addressing the proposed definition and conditions for qualifying performance fees and any operational issues in applying the exemption.
- Firms should consider mapping all management, carried-interest, incentive, performance and underlying-fund charges to determine whether each fee is genuinely calculated solely by reference to investment-performance increases rather than being a disguised administration charge.
- Providers may wish to develop documented decision criteria showing why use of the exemption is in savers' interests, including analysis of expected net returns, risk, liquidity, diversification, costs, conflicts and alternatives.
- Independent Governance Committees should consider whether they will receive sufficiently granular data from providers and underlying managers to evaluate performance-fee calculations, hurdle rates, crystallisation, clawbacks, valuation methods and outcomes for different saver cohorts.
- Firms should consider strengthening private-asset valuation governance, including independent challenge, valuation frequency, methodology oversight and controls addressing conflicts where valuations affect performance fees.
- Providers should review communications, annual reporting and value-for-money assessment processes so that performance-linked fees and their effect on saver outcomes are transparent and fairly allocated.
- Firms may wish to monitor the final rules expected in summer 2027 and avoid treating the consultation proposal as an effective exemption before implementation.
What changed
The FCA proposes to exempt certain performance fees from the existing 0.75% of funds-under-management charge cap applying to qualifying default arrangements in FCA-regulated workplace pension schemes. A fee would need to be calculated solely by reference to increases in investment performance and meet the proposed additional conditions, including requirements concerning commercial necessity, genuine performance, transparency, fairness between savers, valuation governance and due diligence. The exemption would be optional, not a general relaxation of pension charges, and providers would remain expected to demonstrate that higher fees are justified by additional value for savers under the Consumer Duty and applicable value-for-money governance. Providers and Independent Governance Committees
Compliance impact
The proposal is not currently binding and does not change the charge cap before final rules are made. If adopted, it would create a material governance and controls impact for affected pension providers and IGCs: higher fees could be permitted only where qualifying, transparent and demonstrably linked to better saver outcomes, with supervisory and conduct risk if firms use the exemption without ro
Who is affected
Related regulations
References
AI-generated analysis. May contain errors or omissions — verify with the original FCA source before acting. Full disclaimer.
What the FCA said
Workplace pension providers could have greater flexibility to invest for the long term under proposals from the FCA, helping them deliver better outcomes for savers while ensuring savers' interests remain protected. The FCA is consulting on excluding certain performance-linked fees from the charge cap for default…
Extract from FCA . Read the full notice at the source for the authoritative text.