ASIC sues Commonwealth Bank alleging tens of thousands of business customers overcharged fees
AI Analysis
ASIC has commenced Federal Court civil penalty proceedings against Commonwealth Bank of Australia, alleging that CommBiz terms and conditions failed to disclose additional “contra leg” fees charged on Direct Debit and Direct Credit transactions. ASIC alleges approximately 42,000 customers were overcharged about $8.5 million between November 2020 and 31 May 2025, while the underlying misleading terms allegedly existed from CommBiz’s 2006 launch; independent reporting frames the matter as a systemic governance and fee-disclosure failure despite prior complaints, a 2016 internal audit, and completed remediation.
Key dates
- 2025-05-31
- End of the period in which ASIC alleges approximately 42,000 CommBiz customers were overcharged about $8.5 million.
- 2026-02-01
- CBA had begun waiving the relevant contra leg fees for Direct Debit and Direct Credit processing by February 2026.
- 2026-11-12
- ASIC announced commencement of civil penalty proceedings against CBA; the Court had not yet listed a case-management hearing.
Suggested considerations
- Compliance teams may wish to inventory all customer and business-product fees, including charges generated by linked-account, internal-transfer or contra-leg processing, and reconcile those charges to the wording presented in terms, fee schedules, onboarding materials and transaction descriptions.
- Firms should consider testing whether a reasonable customer would understand the total fee payable for each transaction, rather than assessing disclosure only by reference to whether each fee appears somewhere in contractual documentation.
- Banks and other licensees may wish to conduct targeted reviews of complaints, internal-audit findings, product-governance records and unresolved incidents for evidence that a fee or system defect was identified but not corrected.
- Compliance teams may wish to establish controls linking product terms, pricing changes, payment-system configuration and billing outputs, with documented ownership and escalation where those sources diverge.
- Firms should consider reviewing historic transactions and customer cohorts where a fee was charged for many years, assessing whether remediation should include former customers, interest, tax treatment, communications and an accessible claims process.
- Senior management and boards may wish to receive clear reporting on systemic fee issues, complaint trends, remediation completion, control gaps and the effectiveness of corrective actions, particularly where the product is used extensively by small businesses.
- Firms operating under an Australian financial services licence may wish to assess the conduct against the obligation in Corporations Act 2001 section 912A(1)(a) to provide financial services efficiently, honestly and fairly, as well as applicable misleading-conduct and disclosure provisions.
- Compliance teams may wish to monitor the Federal Court proceeding and ASIC’s eventual submissions or judgment for indications on penalty-setting, adverse publicity orders, remediation expectations and the treatment of prior complaints or audit findings.
What changed
No new rule or industry-wide obligation has been introduced by this publication; it is an enforcement action and the allegations remain to be determined by the Court. ASIC is challenging the accuracy and adequacy of CBA’s fee disclosures and alleges failures to act efficiently, honestly and fairly. CBA stopped charging the relevant fees in June 2025, amended the CommBiz Terms in August 2025, and has waived the contra leg fees since February 2026. CBA has also completed remediation covering 1 December 2006 to the present, paying more than $26.4 million to approximately 93,000 customers, including about 40,000 small businesses. ASIC is seeking declarations, pecuniary penalties, adverse publicity orders, ancillary orders and costs.
Compliance impact
The case presents high conduct and governance risk for banks because ASIC alleges that inaccurate fee disclosures persisted for approximately 19 years despite customer complaints from at least 2015 and a 2016 internal audit identifying overcharging. Potential consequences include declarations, pecuniary penalties, adverse publicity, ancillary orders, costs and scrutiny of whether remediation and c
Who is affected
Related regulations
References
- [1] asic.gov.au
- [2] reuters.com third-party
- [3] brisbanetimes.com.au third-party
- [4] riverineherald.com.au third-party
- [5] straitstimes.com third-party
- [6] retailbankerinternational.com third-party
- [7] canberratimes.com.au third-party
- [8] financialstandard.com.au third-party
- [9] 7news.com.au third-party
- [10] smartcompany.com.au third-party
AI-generated analysis. May contain errors or omissions — verify with the original ASIC source before acting. Full disclaimer.
What the ASIC said
ASIC sues Commonwealth Bank alleging tens of thousands of business customers overcharged fees
Published by ASIC . Read the full notice at the source for the authoritative text.